The Titans’ Coaching Crisis: 20 Bold Candidates to Revive a Struggling Franchise
The Tennessee Titans have made a dramatic move by parting ways with head coach Brian Callahan, leaving fans and analysts alike wondering: Who can turn this team around? As we delve into the reasons behind this decision—which we explored in depth two weeks ago—it’s clear that Callahan’s tenure was marked by inconsistency, particularly after a historic meltdown by the Cardinals in Week 5, followed by another lackluster offensive performance against the Raiders. But here’s where it gets controversial: Was Callahan truly the problem, or is the Titans’ struggle a symptom of deeper organizational issues? Either way, the team now has the earliest head start in this year’s coaching market, giving new general manager Mike Borgonzi ample time to evaluate candidates. This hire is critical, not just for the future of No. 1 pick Cam Ward—a talent who’s thrived despite a lack of structure—but also for the Titans’ ability to attract fans and sponsors to their new Nashville stadium. Leadership, not just quarterback development, is reportedly the top priority. And this is the part most people miss: the Titans are determined to avoid the rushed, infatuation-driven process that led to Callahan’s hiring in the first place.
With that in mind, here are 20 candidates who could step into this high-pressure role, each bringing unique strengths and potential controversies. Let’s dive in—and don’t be afraid to voice your agreement or disagreement in the comments!
1. Matt Nagy
Once a polarizing figure, Nagy’s stock is rising again after his success with Mitch Trubisky and his role in the Chiefs’ functional offense. But does he deserve another shot after his Bears tenure? His past work with Borgonzi could tip the scales.
2. Arthur Smith
A fan favorite during his Titans tenure, Smith transformed the offense for Derrick Henry. Yet, his Falcons stint ended abruptly. Is he a proven leader or a one-trick pony? His successor’s struggles might give him a second chance.
3. Kliff Kingsbury
Kingsbury’s innovative offense with Jayden Daniels has reignited interest in him. But after organizational chaos with the Cardinals, will he risk another turbulent situation? His Texas roots might make the Titans appealing—or not.
4. Marcus Freeman
Freeman’s NFL-ready leadership at Notre Dame makes him a compelling candidate. But can a college coach truly transition to the pros? His ability to sell a vision could be exactly what the Titans need.
5. Eddie George
A Titans legend, George’s turnaround at Tennessee State is impressive. But is his coaching experience enough for the NFL? He’d fit the leadership-first mantra, but can he handle the pressure?
6. Mike Kafka
Kafka’s work with the Giants’ offense has turned heads, especially after a recent win over a Vic Fangio defense. But is he ready for a head coaching role? His diversity coaching accolades add an intriguing layer.
7. Vance Joseph
Joseph’s disastrous Broncos tenure was marred by quarterback issues. But his defensive success since then is undeniable. Does he deserve a second chance? His current unit leads the league in EPA per play.
8. Alex Grizzard
Following in the footsteps of Buccaneers’ OC success stories, Grizzard has helped Baker Mayfield become an MVP candidate. But is he ready for the top job? His Yale background and Dolphins roots are impressive.
9. Robert Saleh
Saleh’s Jets tenure was derailed by ownership meddling, but he’s thrived in San Francisco. Can he rebuild his reputation? His emotional leadership could be a game-changer for the Titans.
10. Joe Brady
Brady’s work with the Bills has made them one of the most balanced offenses in the league. But can he handle a head coaching role after a rocky stop in Carolina? His LSU success is hard to ignore.
11. Klint Kubiak
Kubiak’s efficient offense in Seattle has generated buzz. But is he more than just his father’s legacy? His patience and interpersonal skills could make him a strong leader.
12. Adam Stenavich
Stenavich’s work in Green Bay has transformed their running game. But can he call plays at the head coaching level? His tough-guy personality with a dry humor might resonate with players.
13. Kirk Monken
Monken’s impact on Lamar Jackson’s career is undeniable, but can he lead a team? His head coaching experience at Southern Miss and player-favorite status at Georgia are strong selling points.
14. Jesse Minter
Minter’s defensive prowess with the Chargers has kept them competitive despite injuries. But is he ready for the top job? His Ravens and Michigan experience make him a rising star.
15. Joe Shula
Shula’s pressure-heavy defense has the Rams back in contention. But can he handle the offensive side? His pedigree and podium skills make him a compelling candidate.
16. Brian Flores
Flores’s player-led defense is a hit, but he was overlooked last year. Is the NFL ready for his guerilla approach? His tumultuous Dolphins tenure might be a red flag—or a learning curve.
17. Mike Campanile
Campanile’s turnover-heavy defense in Jacksonville has revived the Jaguars. But is he more than a one-year wonder? His blueblood coaching background adds credibility.
18-20: The Three Musketeers (Webb, Doyle, Udinski)
These up-and-coming coordinators are on the fast track but aren’t play-callers yet. Are they ready for the leap? Webb’s NFL experience, Doyle’s youth, and Udinski’s quarterback development make them intriguing wildcards.
Final Thoughts
The Titans’ coaching search is more than just a hiring process—it’s a statement about the franchise’s future. With leadership as the top priority, who do you think should take the reins? And more importantly, can anyone truly fix what’s broken in Tennessee? Let the debate begin!
